The Real Estate Industry Awaits a Return to Normalcy and Focuses on Tenants, not Valuations
Stephanie M. Zaleski-Braatz
One thing that the real estate industry has had to learn from the economic cycles of the past three decades and from crises like the savings and loan collapse is patience.
On the surface, the global pandemic seems to have had a uniform impact on the global economy — the tendency is to look at the big picture impact on national economies, job losses and stock markets. While there is no arguing that the effects of this singular event in modern history will be felt and studied for years to come, the devil is in the details.
There are varying realities amongst those who own real estate assets across different sectors and around the country. The restaurant industry has been hit harder than others. Yet within the restaurant industry itself, there is variation: Many fast-food and quick-serve concepts are thriving, while others, like fine dining, are struggling.
For the real estate industry, lessons learned from past cycles and crises are translating into wait-and-see mode. Sellers are not willing to meet buyers’ expectations. On the commercial side, 61% of buyers expected a discount from pre-pandemic prices while only 9% of sellers were willing to offer them, according to CBRE’s Q3 2020 Cap Rate Report. While some institutional investors may expect to see more distressed deals, unlike the Great Recession of 2008, there is significantly more capital sitting on the sidelines, enabling would-be sellers to wait out the current disruption.
With the vaccine rollout well underway, the questions for those with real estate holdings are: How soon will the return to normal occur? Will we be dealing with a new normal? What can be done in the meantime? And, how can we position ourselves for the upside?
Lending has tightened, but banks are still willing to be flexible
Since the Great Recession, when banks ended up owning and taking losses on real estate assets that borrowers could no longer make payments on, banks have been hesitant to foreclose on properties in default. Today, they are looking closely at de-risking their loan portfolios, and in some cases, selling debt to private credit funds to reduce losses. The private credit funds look at this as a way to become owners of real property at a lower price point.
Many banks and real estate owners are waiting for a recovery, as they know from history that the economy eventually comes around. In the meantime, banks have also allowed late or delayed payments or let borrowers tap into loan reserves to meet payment deadlines.
Office and retail real estate
More than any other sector in the industry, offices will look very different post-pandemic. The new reality that employees can — and want to— work remotely, at least part of the time, has forced conversations about contingency plans for how office space and layouts should look going forward, what the new demand for square footage may be, the extent to which companies will move to a hub-and-spoke or hybrid model and the comeback of coworking. Office landlords will need to sell more of an experience as opposed to just space. That experience could center around additional concierge-type services to suit evolving office tenant needs.
Cap rates for offices vary based on location and occupancy. For a fully occupied prime office location, particularly in central business districts like New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago, deals have closed at around 6%, down to 4% for trophy assets. Underscoring the theme of variation within segments, cap rates for niche office segments like life sciences remain lower than non-life sciences properties, as demand for these types of defensive properties rises. In terms of new office leases in 2020, the tech sector accounted for 18% of the top 100 leases, according to CBRE. National cap rates for the office sector in the third quarter of 2020 were 7.12%, closely in line with the five-year rolling average of 7.16%, according to CBRE.
If they are not already, office buildings with vacant ground-floor retail or restaurant space should be considering leasing to life sciences or medical businesses, which are and will continue to be in high demand. Meanwhile, the conversion of second-and higher-floor office space, as well as shuttered hotels, for residential use is expected to continue to increase.
Retail and restaurants/hospitality have seen the greatest disruption; retail brick-and-mortar closures are expected to range from 20,000 to 25,000 stores in 2021, on top of the more than 10,000 store closures that already occurred in 2020.
Retail cap rates have increased for freestanding net lease real estate, while for retailers seen as defensive, such as Dollar General, cap rates have declined 50 basis points at most. On the flip side, for typically well-occupied properties seeing vacancies, cap rates have increased 50 to 75 basis points. Cap rates for assets of troubled retailers are, of course, much higher.
Mom-and-pop or unique retail tenants, such as shoemakers or instrument repair shops, who were priced out of central business districts or high-rent downtown areas, may see an opportunity to return to cities. Landlords who were willing to go for years advertising vacant retail space may be more willing to consider working with such prospects on affordable lease terms.
Lease terms should be top of mind, of course. Tenants with less than a year left on their leases are likely surveying the market for alternatives, depending on their evolving workplace needs. Landlords should be willing to work with them to accommodate these needs and to renegotiate leases.
Industrial real estate
Industrial real estate has been the most resilient sector of real estate throughout the pandemic, in large part due to the increase in demand for e-commerce as the U.S. population largely sheltered in place. As such, the largest distribution tenants — Amazon and Walmart, for example—have been fueling the sector’s success. The average cap rate is 6.2% for industrial sales, falling by 119 basis points over the course of 2020, according to CoStar data. However, for Class A properties, cap rates are lower — 4.3%, which represents a decline of 171 basis points from the fourth quarter of 2019, according to CoStar.
Industrial tenants’ new needs (e.g., on-demand warehousing) have altered business as usual for landlords. E-commerce sales are estimated to hit $1.5 trillion by 2025, creating demand for one billion square feet of industrial space, according to JLL.
Suburban migration’s impact
The great migration to the suburbs is driving single-family home values up; multifamily home values remain steady and cap rates have compressed. In central business districts, the story is a little different. Multifamily class B and C properties are seeing vacancies rise and the cap rate increase about 50 basis points.
Suburban landlords and developers should be aware that urban migrants will take with them their desire for urban amenities. Ultimately, urban tastes may help support suburban businesses like restaurants, which will also see support from a surge in demand for in-person dining as more of the U.S. population gets vaccinated.
Many industries, as we approach a return to normalcy, may be quite altered from how they looked pre-pandemic. Brick-and-mortar retailers will continue to give way to e-commerce, offices will need to be overhauled and locations across sectors will migrate from cities to more suburban locations. At the same time, those who previously could not afford urban real estate may seek to move to central business districts if the lease terms are right.
Real estate owners are not panicking. As the vaccine rollout continues and the light at the end of the pandemic tunnel is approaching, deal-making will pick up. With $300 billion of global available capital for real estate investment—much of which is aimed at North America, according to CBRE — willingness to sell at discounted prices will remain elusive.
For more information, contact Stephanie Zaleski-Braatz at [email protected] or 312.670.7444. Visit ORBA.com to learn more about our Real Estate Group.